I’ve read a lot recently about budgets and spending plans, and why some people prefer spending plans over budgets for their flexibility and ability to plan and chart goals into the future. The idea is that charting where your money goes as it comes in and goes out (a spending plan) is less likely for failure than deciding where your money will go before it shows up and then making sure it goes there when it does (a budget). A spending plan allows for change, for life, for happenstance. A budget is rigid, proscriptive, and doesn’t allow you to live life as it happens. If something unexpected happens, you’re breaking the budget. The budget drives you – whereas you drive the spending plan.
But I contend that a budget done well is basically similar to a spending plan – in fact, it’s really two sides of the same coin. A well-crafted budget is a spending plan that has a name with a bad rap. In fact, I contend that many would call my own budget a spending plan, because I allow flexibility when I need it, and look at it as a fluid, ever-evolving process. My budget gives me the ability to really look at my financial priorities and decide what is important to me before I start spending. I vote with my dollars, so to speak, by deciding where I would like them to go. But a spending plan does this as well – just after the fact. You vote with your dollars, and then just see how the dollars voted at the end.
I prefer to pretend I have some voluntary control over it all. But that doesn’t mean I never adjust my budget or change things midstream. I just make an ideal plan of how I would like things to go first. And then edit as needed along the way.
In uncertain economic times, we all want to be in the most prepared position possible. Today is not too late to start improving your financial future. Even if you have to trick yourself into doing it. For the 1000th published post on I’ve Paid For This Twice Already… , I’m sharing my favorite five mental money hacks all in one place.
Thanks for being a part of my journey and I can’t wait until we go from the “debt elimination” phase to the “hoarding a wad of cash” phase!
A comment on a previous post, which I cannot at the moment find (edit: Mandi emailed me to let me know it was her on this post) mentioned how they follow the idea of meal planning out of their pantry vs out of circulars, because they shop in a way that they know they’ve spent the least amount possible for everything in their pantry. They buy items when they are the least expensive, and then look to their pantry and what they have stocked to decide what to make that week for meals.
This is exactly what my goal is with the unit price comparison shopping I discussed yesterday. I stock up on items when they are on sale so that I never “have” to buy those items when they are at full price. A simple concept but one it has taken me a long while to catch onto and effectively put into practice.
Our grocery list used to have 25-30 items on it every week. Last week, before I added the sale/stock up items, the number of items on the list we needed to buy was 7. Milk, grapes, apples, cheese, yogurt, potatoes, and wheat pitas. I bought more things than that, because I bought a number of items on sale paired with coupons (I always enjoy Mini-Wheats cereal for $0.50 per box). But the list of things we were out of and needed was only 7. This is my goal. Buy what’s on sale, and what is perishable and needs to be replaced weekly, and plan my meals based on what I have stocked. And I stocked up on potatoes this week.
And then maybe once everything is stocked up – buy some chocolate.
Next in my “You can get out of debt – give yourself some peace of mind in this crazy economy” series this week is the idea of budgeting. I’ve written about budgeting and how I budget in the past, and you can get caught up here:
Today I don’t want to talk about the specifics of budgeting as much as I do the specifics of the budgeting software I use, and some tips and tricks for using it most efficiently. This isn’t for everyone – no matter what your budgeting software preference, the important part is that you budget (or devise a spending plan, or whatever you would like to call it). But for those who have never tried budgeting before, I thoughtinsight into the hacks I’ve devised for the budgeting program I use may be helpful.
I use the spreadsheet version of PearBudget. It is a free downloadable spreadsheet that you can use to keep track of all the money flowing in and out of your household. I like having something on my computer that I enter the data into. There are other programs that will automatically download your bank and credit card transactions, and if that is what you like, that’s great. I like doing things the old fashioned way, it makes me feel more connected to my spending. This is an excel worksheet (I use it in OpenOffice, a freeware program) that has done all the coding work for me as far as making numbers go to the right places. That makes me happy.
When you download the PearBudget spreadsheet, the first thing you’ll do is create your monthly budget. PearBudget uses a monthly system and a yearly summary. There are categories for regular expenses, variable expenses, and irregular expenses. Regular expenses are those that are the same every month – mine are things like our mortgage and car insurance payment. Variable expenses are those that vary per month, such as groceries and gasoline. Irregular expenses are those that aren’t every month but need to be accounted for – I include all our annual expenses as well as things like clothing, medical, and haircuts. You have ten slots for each category – it isn’t necessary to fill up all ten slots, but try to remember all the different categories in which you spend money. If the total comes out higher than your monthly income, you’ll need to adjust some categories downwards.
Now for the hacks. Move on to a specific month, like October. Just because, well, it is October.
You’ll see that on the left side are the days of the month in number form, and on the right side a column that you can enter your income into as it comes in too. In the middle and on the bottom are the categories you entered on the first page. I had one problem. The irregular expenses don’t have any monetary amount associated with them on the monthly sheets (the variable does, and the regular should be regular so you don’t need to remember them necessarily). I wanted to be able to track how I was doing as far as spending the irregular categories. Enter the “note” function. If you right-click on any cell, you can enter a note that will be associated with that cell. I love notes. I use notes all the time. I put notes to describe:
My next hack is in regards to dealing with the monthly budget. My first month using PearBudget went swimmingly, and I matched my ending balance on my budget sheet to my bank balance. I continued with the next month, and something went wrong – I couldn’t match the bank balance and the budget remainder at the end of the month. After a lot of pondering, the solution was simple – because this is based on month to month, I need to enter the remaining balance from one month as income on the next to carry it into that month.
The last hack I use is highlighting in regards to income. I use not only notes, but the cell color to make sure our different sources of income get allocated correctly. I snowflake all of our extra incidental income (from surveys, the blog, my part time jobs) towards debt, and to make sure it goes to debt and not anywhere else, I change the cell color to purple until it is applied to debt, and then to yellow once it is applied. that way when I look at my snowflake savings account, I can figure out where all the money in it came from quickly, and keep track of when it gets moved to paying off debt. I lose track of less incidentals this way.
Those, in a nutshell, are my three PearBudget hacks to make using it suited to my needs. Play around with the program – don’t be afraid to mess with things and see what happens. Like budgeting itself, a good budgeting tool is flexible and adjusts to your own needs.
The price of everything is going up. This is an inevitable fact of life, but it seems lately, things are going up faster than pay increases can keep up with it. Sometimes, even when we’re buying the exact same things we bought the month or year before, they cost significantly more.
So what can you do when the price of everything is more, but you can’t afford to spend more? Like my post yesterday, I am going to use our grocery budget as my example of ways to control spending. I, in fact, did increase our grocery budget. However, I limited the increase to 5%, while the increased consumption from my kids coupled with the increased prices indicated a 20% increase would have made more sense from the data I collected. I used many of the following strategies to help bridge the gap between rising costs and not enough money to go around.
1. Identify wants versus needs. When looking at my grocery spending, I would put purchases into categories based on being on my list versus being an impulsive purchase. But with the belt-tightening in face of rising costs, I had to go further. I started analyzing the list itself and determining what we truly needed versus what we just preferred to enhance our quality of life. Then I had a better idea of what I could start cutting or coming up with alternatives for.
2. Meal plan. Having an actual set 7 day meal plan gave me a much better grasp on what we were actually spending each week on our meals. I could calculate the per serving cost of each meal, and get a realistic idea of what I was spending per person and per day. Then I could look at which meals were beyond our budget.
3. Shop for staples vs shopping for meals. This might sound contrary to #2, but really it is not. Limiting your meals to just what is on sale can be a good short term strategy, but what happens when the circulars don’t have any meal combinations you can afford? Being able to be flexible and stock up on staples when they are on sale, and use them over time, will yield more long-term savings than being tied to only buying what you need in a particular week. Then, going forward, you can combine these staples you have with what is on sale and come up with inexpensive meals.
4. Know the unit prices of everything. The only way to really recognize good deals is to know what a good price is. Every box has a different amount in it lately. Calculate your per unit prices, and then you can compare across brands and stores.
5. Find substitutions. Sometimes something you need just gets too expensive. Be open to trying different brands, different stores, different options. Try a different type of meat. Try a meat-free meal. Look at what you can substitute without losing health value.
6. Become more self-reliant. As far as shopping goes, our very first step in becoming self-reliant was to plant two tomato plants this year. Next year, we plan a full-blown garden. This is something I have only started to explore but could yield significant cost savings on produce as well as provide an enjoyable hobby for my family.
A combination of yesterday’s tips and today’s helped me understand my spending, know where I could be flexible, and ultimately keep the increase to a minimum. And if I had to keep it from increasing at all, I think I could have done that (but with more sacrifice on our part than I was willing to make at this time).